The Tenant of Wildfell Hall

‘You must go back with me to the autumn of 1827’ writes Gilbert Markham to his friend Jack Halford in 1847, ‘I know you like a long story, and are as great a stickler for particularities and circumstantial details as my grandmother, so I will not spare you’ and so he begins to recount the story of his meeting with Helen Graham. Gloomy Wildfell Hall has been shut for years, but word comes to the neighbourhood that a mysterious single lady has been seen occupying a few of the rooms with a young child. The chatter begins amongst the local families as they speculate and vie for information and invitations.

We know that she’s an artist, that she is alone with her son Arthur and one trustworthy servant and we know that there’s a secret and that she’s afraid – but what has happened? Helen takes Gilbert into her confidence and dramatically thrusts her diary into his hands.

‘Bring it back when you have read it; and don’t breathe a word of what it tells you to any living being – I trust to your honour.’

And so we learn about Helen’s past. Living with her uncle and aunt they take her to London for the season where against all advice she determines to marry Arthur Huntingdon, a handsome ‘wildish’ young man. As the diary goes on and the months become years, Huntingdon’s already obnoxious behaviour becomes increasingly cruel. Now parents’ Huntingdon fills the house with his friends (including the unscrupulous Annabella and her weak willed husband), for months at a time. Always drunk they goad Helen by plying the toddler with alcohol and encouraging him to abuse his mother while they fall about laughing, which in turn the child loves. Finally he moves his mistress into the house and Helen is trapped. But she is resolved to save her son and to do this she must escape, make an independent life and successfully earn her living. Written in 1848 this is powerful stuff, Helen is flouting the law as well as shocking social conventions as women and children were still the subject of their husbands control.

Anne Brontë was writing from experience as she had lived with her brother Branwell’s addictions and knowledge of his affair with the mistress of the house in which they were both employed. She says that she wishes ‘to tell the truth’ with this story and I thought there was a clarity and honesty in the writing that made it painfully real. Brontë doesn’t play to our sympathies, Helen is not a warm character, she is bound by a sense of christian duty and piousness which I found very boring but the sense of deterioration goes beyond their marriage; for just as Huntingdon is lost in addiction, trying to keep up with his younger friends, so Helen becomes hard and embittered, older than her years.

Brontë felt bitterly that education was to blame. That boys are taught to ‘rush into the snares of life,- to seek temptation for the sake of exercising (their) virtue by overcoming it’, whilst girls are taught ‘to be tenderly and delicately nurtured,- taught to cling to others for direction and support, and guarded, as much as possible, from the very knowledge of evil.’ So that neither is actually prepared for life. Helen, in her naiveté is full of self-righteousness, sure that she can change Huntingdon on their marriage and save his soul, even though all the signs are there of his worthless character; and Huntingdon has been indulged all his life, he’s utterly selfish, treating everyone that doesn’t humour him with scorn and ridicule leaving him an easy target for swindlers and hangers on.

But despite the intense emotions recorded in the diary entries I’m afraid this narrative device kept me removed from them, so that it felt strangely flat for such high drama. I wish Helen was telling Gilbert about her past, a conversation would have felt much more alive. But at the end of the diary the narrative moves back to Gilbert’s letters and the story telling becomes much more lively. A cast of characters, conversation, misunderstandings and carriages that move swiftly through the night. I won’t give away the ending but I do love the constant excitement of Gilbert’s voice:

‘Winged by this hope, and goaded by these fears, I hurried homewards to prepare for my departure on the morrow.’

He brings some much needed gaiety!

I read that this was an immediate success on publication, it must have caused an enormous stir with its frank view of a marriage. In 1848 she wrote a preface to the second edition where she spells out her aim:

‘My object in writing the following pages, was not simply to amuse the Reader. . . I know that such characters do exist, and if I have warned one rash youth from following in their steps, or prevented one thoughtless girl from falling into the very natural error of my heroine, the book has not been written in vain.’

Despite my problems with the diary device I’m very glad to have read this and really admire Anne Brontë for being so outspoken in her complete belief in equality and the importance of education and am looking forward to Agnes Grey.

26 thoughts on “The Tenant of Wildfell Hall

    1. I completely agree there is nothing faintly romantic about him – I kept wanting to use the word louche, but I thought that carried an undertone of charisma and there is nothing heroic or attractive about him.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. I know what you mean, there were times in the diary entries when she was so ‘holier than thou’ that I had no patience with her at all, but I think it was clever to give us a heroine that isn’t easy to like and put her in this abominable situation. Have you read Agnes Grey?

      Liked by 1 person

      1. You’re right, keeping us interested when we don’t like the characters using their situation doesn’t happen all that often.
        Yes, I’ve read Agnes Grey. If I remember correctly, I particularly disliked the children and their families in this book and felt sorry for the main character.
        I’m going to check your posts now to see if you’ve read Agnes Grey 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you Jacqui, I certainly don’t think everyone sees the diary as a flaw and maybe if Helen had been telling her story Bronte wouldn’t have been able to make such a pitch for Huntingdon’s need for salvation which she took so seriously.

      Like

  1. You’ve succeeded in tempting me, Jane. This is a book I’ve shied away from ever since reading Shirley, which I found quite slow. Having said that, I’ve always been glad I did give it the time, so I guess the same applies to this one, so I’m revising my decision. Thank you.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I loved this book and didn’t really have a problem with the diary structure, although it did take me a while to adjust to the change in narrator and I agree that the piousness is annoying! I enjoyed Agnes Grey too and I think it’s a shame Anne doesn’t get as much recognition as Emily and Charlotte.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I completely agree that Anne should have just as much recognition, with her goals and beliefs I’m surprised she doesn’t. I’m looking forward to Agnes Grey too.

      Like

  3. Wow! What a wonderful review! I am going to put this on my classics spin list. The book seems like it was ahead of its time. I love stories that deal with women’s issues. And especially if they have a rebellious streak, Thank you!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Anne became my favourite Bronte on the strength of this book. I was expecting it to be a real effort but I loved it. I agree with all the points you make about the characters and feeling removed from them and the story because of the diary device, Jane, and yet I still loved it. It was so scandalous for its time and defied convention; it was such a risky book to write and then to publish! You’ve made me want to read it again but perhaps that would spoil it for me. Agnes Grey, on the other hand, I found quite flat. Nothing wrong with it, just predictable and rather dull.

    Should you be interested, my review is here: https://acornerofcornwall.com/2016/07/21/the-tenant-of-wildfell-hall-by-anne-bronte/ It doesn’t add anything to what you’ve already said here, Jane!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I didn’t read your review because I will be re-reading that novel in the next weeks (next week ?) so I’ll keep it in mind and return discussing it with you when I’m done. Love the Brontës, so, so much !

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes very daring, readers must have been scandalised as well as educated (hopefully) and for any reader in an abusive marriage it must have been like finding a confidant. Amazing!

      Like

  6. The Brontes are still a massive gap in my reading – I’ve only read a couple, and not this one. They do seem to have had an amazingly modern outlook on life, surprising for women with such restricted lives. It’s interesting to speculate whether any one of them would have the courage to write as they did, if they hadn’t had the support of their sisters…

    Liked by 1 person

    1. an interesting point about support, Anne was definitely helped along with the actual publishing but I was struck by how autobiographical this was. It seems her life wasn’t quite as restricted as I thought, read it and see what you think!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s