Sense and Sensibility

‘The family of Dashwood had been long settled in Sussex.’

I love that opening line, the words can’t be read quickly, they seem to have a slow authority that tell us what to expect. That this is a family drama, about an old family and it hints that change is afoot. We know straight away to settle in and allow ourselves to be wrapped up in their story.

The Dashwood sisters, Elinor and Marianne are forced to leave Norland, their family home when their father dies and their brother John inherits the estate. They take up a cottage in Devonshire with their mother and younger sister Margaret and it’s from here that they must navigate their way to matrimony and happiness whilst avoiding the stumbling blocks of Lucy Steele and Willoughby.

Society in Devonshire revolves around some distant relatives, Sir John and Lady Middleton and their mother in law, Mrs Jennings. Sir John and Mrs Jennings are huge, fun characters who get themselves involved in everyone’s business and use teasing as there means of communication. But they also provide some eligible bachelors in the shape of Willoughby and Colonel Brandon, a mischief maker in Lucy Steele and a house in London from which Elinor and Marianne can take part in the London Season. Also in London is their horribly grasping sister in law, Fanny who through pitch perfect accuracy Jane Austen is able to highlight the hypocrisy and shallowness of polite society.

I read that this was originally going to be called ‘Elinor and Marianne’, and it is really a novel about the two sisters. Wild, joyous Marianne who never attempts to behave with propriety and is led astray from the start, by the dastardly Willoughby, and sensible, responsible Elinor who attempts to keep some sort of order while cherishing the hope of a quiet future with Edward Ferrars.

The difference in the sisters’ characters is most obvious in the way they deal with heartbreak. The quiet contained sorrow of Elinor is for us heartbreaking while we see her soothing Marianne who includes everybody she knows (and many she doesn’t) in her own unhappiness. But Jane Austen is so clever at drawing people that I don’t think she sees it as simply as country v town, or wildness v quietness. And this comes out in their teasing of each other. Elinor can see the fun in Marianne and although exasperated by her behaviour enjoys her liveliness, and while Marianne needs to learn to be more measured in her actions it’s not at the cost of her enthusiasm.

Matrimony is where sense and sensibility collide and both sisters know that this is serious business. And not only for women, there’s nothing prudish about Willoughby’s treatment of vulnerable young girls but by giving him some time to try and explain himself we can see how important social standing is, even to a ‘libertine‘. But also by doing this I think Jane Austen pits Willoughby’s marriage and the cold competitive wrangling of Fanny and the scheming Lucy Steele against the warmth of the Dashwood family.

14 thoughts on “Sense and Sensibility

  1. Some good points here about the novel not being just about opposites. My impression when I first read this was that it was as much about sly humour as about the story and the main protagonists (

    Eventually I hope to reread all six of the published novels and see if my responses remain the same, and I’m curious to see if I view S&S in the same way — at the moment it’s not my favourite (Mansfield Park has that accolade) but I happy to revise my opinion.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I had only read Emma years ago and thought I should give them all a go. So far Northanger Abbey and S&S have been delightful, I’m looking forward to comparing them all when I finish – all these sisters!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I love this one – I actually think it’s her best at showing how society and the matrimonial market works, although P&P is more entertaining. But Marianne and Elinor’s eventual marriages feel much more realistic than Lizzie’s glittering match. Especially Elinor, who is such a wonderful character – far too good for Edward if you ask me! But she’ll give him the steadiness and strength of character he so clearly lacks… 😉

    I assume you’ve seen the movie adaptation with Emma Thompson as Elinor and Kate Winslet as Marianne – if not, you must! It’s wonderful…

    Liked by 3 people

    1. Yes, I love Ang Lee’s version with Emma and Kate, I especially think Harriet Walter as Fanny is brilliant. I haven’t read P&P yet, but I can agree that Marianne and Elinor feel very realistic. I do love Elinor and thought she was a very subtle character, sensible yes ( is this partly because she has to be?) but not without fun. P&P is next!

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you Sandra, I definitely think this is a book that makes it to the cosy reads pile! The first time I saw the Emma Thompson film I thought the casting was a bit odd, but actually they’re perfect aren’t they?


  3. Count me as another fan of the Ang Lee/Emma Thompson adaptation. In fact, that’s what I remember most clearly about the story as it’s been so long since I actually read the book! Austen was so good at exposing the shallowness and hypocrisies of her society. She reminds me of Edith Wharton in that respect – a completely different time and place, but the principles are much the same.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. ooh I’m glad you’ve said that because I’ve got an Edith Wharton lined up, so I might read that next to compare. I do think Fanny Dashwood is one of the best characters in the book and film!


  4. It has been a while since I’ve read this, but since Austen’s novels can easily be reread, I might pick it up again some time. As mentioned earlier, I don’t have a favourite Austen, but probably the choice would be between S&S, P&P and Persuasion. I find the dynamics between Marianne and Elinor more interesting than the relations between the P&P sisters.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. It’s time for me to re read the book after your wonderful review! I remember enjoying reading it but that was a few decades ago. For some reason the two sisters reminded me of Margaret and Helen Schlegel, the sisters from Forster’s “ Howards End”.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s